A Wrapper for the Blacksmith Shop in Geneva

April 29, 2026

By Preservation Partners of the Fox Valley (reprinted with permission)

There are more questions than answers in this latest development of Geneva’s mid-1840s blacksmith shop.

On Wednesday, April 22, 2026, workers installed a white wrap around all but the chimneys of the mid-1840s Alexander brothers’ blacksmith shop located at 4 E. State Street in Geneva. Why this was done has left many questions, and – so far – there are few answers.

A photo of the Geneva Blacksmith Shop wrapped in white plastic.

WHAT WE KNOW AS OF APRIL 30

  • No one that we contacted at the City of Geneva appeared to be aware that this wrap would be installed.

  • A city permit does not appear to have been applied for or issued. A Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) from Geneva’s Historic Preservation Commission was not considered or approved. (However, whether a city permit or COA was required for this work is unknown.)

  • The wrap appears to be made of some kind of plastic.

  • The wrap may have been applied in an effort to satisfy the building maintenance codes that the City determined, and the Kane County Circuit Court affirmed, had been violated, resulting in a $750 daily fine to the property owner since October 2024.

WHAT WE DON’T KNOW AS OF APRIL 30

  • Will this wrap protect the building from further deterioration, or could moisture be trapped inside and accelerate deterioration?

  • Will this wrap clear up the building maintenance code violations for which the city has fined the owner since October 2024 at $750 per day?

  • What is the status of the over $400,000 in fines assessed as of April 30, 2026?

At this point, there are many more questions than answers about the white wrap now encasing this historic blacksmith shop.

Previous
Previous

What’s at Stake with Geneva’s Blacksmith Shop?